Undertow
Translating this chapter into اردو — this page refreshes when it's ready.

Chapter 4

The Longest Day

She messaged him at seven in the morning. He was already awake. He was always already awake.

Oise_88 (PM): He's gone. Work trip. He left at six. He won't be back until tomorrow afternoon.

NorthForeland (PM): How do you feel?

Oise_88 (PM): Guilty.

NorthForeland (PM): And?

Oise_88 (PM): Free. Which makes the guilt worse.

NorthForeland (PM): I know.

Oise_88 (PM): I have the whole day. The whole house. I don't have to whisper.

NorthForeland (PM): What do you want to do with it?

Oise_88 (PM): Everything.

He called her ten minutes later. No video. Just voice. She picked up on the second ring and the first thing he heard was the difference. No whisper. No careful, hushed tone. Her voice was full. Open. Filling a room instead of hiding in one. It was like hearing a song he'd only known as a demo suddenly played with a full band.

"Morning," she said.

"Morning. What does your kitchen look like right now?"

She laughed. "Why?"

"Tell me. I want to picture it."

"Um. Sun's coming through the window. The table I showed you. There's a mug. Tea, not coffee. The cat is on the windowsill."

"You have a cat?"

"I have a cat. She's grey. She's old. She doesn't care about anything."

"I love her already."

"She'd hate you. She hates everyone."

"Sounds like she and I have something in common."

She laughed again and the sound was different in daylight. Brighter. Less guarded. He was lying on his bed in Folkestone with the curtains open, the gray English light washing the room in a pale, watery glow. He could hear her world through the phone. The tick of a clock. The creak of a chair. The distant sound of nothing, which was the sound of the countryside.

"Show me," he said.

"What?"

"Show me the kitchen. The cat. The morning. I want to see it."

She hesitated. Then a photo arrived. The kitchen in daylight. It was different from the night photo. Warmer. More alive. The window was open and he could see the garden beyond it, a small patch of green, a stone wall, and beyond that, fields. The cat was on the windowsill, a fat grey blur, exactly as described. The table had a mug on it and a book and the light was gold and slanted and he could see dust motes suspended in the air.

"It's perfect," he said.

"It's a kitchen."

"It's your kitchen. That's what makes it perfect."

"You're ridiculous."

"I'm consistent. That's worth something."

They started with nothing. No toy. No controls. No agenda. Just the phone call, open and running, the way you leave a door open between two rooms. He made coffee. She made more tea. They moved through their separate mornings in parallel, narrating the small things. The taste of the coffee. The sound of the cat jumping down from the windowsill. The way the light changed on his wall as the sun shifted.

"Show me outside," he said.

She took the phone to the garden. He heard the door open, the change in acoustics from enclosed to open, the sudden vastness of outside sound. Birds. Wind. The particular quality of silence that rural France produced, which wasn't silence at all but a layered hum of living things.

"Describe it to me," she said. "Where you are."

He took his phone to the window. "I'm looking at the Channel. It's gray today. Not angry gray. Tired gray. The kind of gray that's been gray for so long it's forgotten there are other colors."

"That's depressing."

"It's honest. I like honest."

"What else?"

"The cliffs. You can't see them from here but I know they're there. White chalk. They crumble sometimes. Pieces fall into the sea and the sea takes them and they're gone. I think about that a lot. How even the solid things don't last."

"You think about geology to feel sad?"

"I think about geology to feel less alone in being eroded."

She was quiet for a moment. Then, softly: "That's the most you thing you've ever said."

He smiled. She couldn't see it but she could hear it, he knew she could, because she made a small sound in response, a hum of satisfaction, like she'd found something she'd been looking for.

At ten in the morning, she paired her toy.

Not because he asked. Because she wanted to. She told him so plainly, without the usual apology or hedging.

"I want you to have me today. All day. Not just for a session. I want you to have the controls whenever you want."

He felt the weight of that. It was more than a slider. It was access. She was handing him the keys to her body for an entire day and trusting that he wouldn't abuse it. Or maybe trusting that he would, and wanting him to.

"I'll be gentle," he said.

"I don't want you to be gentle. I want you to be you."

He started her at twelve percent. A low, constant hum that she could feel but wasn't overwhelming. Enough to keep her aware of him. Enough to remind her that he was there, holding the controls, present in her body even across the water.

She gasped softly when it started. Then settled into it. He could hear her breathing change on the phone, a slight quickening, a slight deepening, and then she continued her morning as if nothing was happening, except that everything was happening.

"Tell me about where you grew up," she said.

He told her. A town in Kent. Not Folkestone. Smaller. Further inland. A village where nothing happened and the nothing was so total it became its own kind of violence. He told her about his parents, his mother who was warm but overwhelmed, his father who was present but absent, the specific loneliness of being an only child in a house where the adults were too tired to notice what was happening beneath the surface.

"When did you first know you were different?" she asked.

"I was eight. A boy in my class was crying. Not loudly. Quietly. In the corner. Everyone else was doing a worksheet. I could feel his sadness like a frequency. Like a sound only I could hear. I went and sat next to him and didn't say anything. Just sat there. He stopped crying after a while and looked at me and said how did you know. And I didn't have an answer. I still don't."

"That's not broken."

"It is when you can't turn it off."

He nudged the slider to fifteen percent. She caught her breath.

"Keep talking," she whispered.

"About what?"

"About the things you think are broken. I want to know all of them."

He told her. He told her about the self-hatred. Not in abstract terms. In specific, granular detail. The way he looked in the mirror and saw a face that didn't match the person inside it. The way he rehearsed conversations before having them and then replayed them after, cataloging every mistake. The way he couldn't accept a compliment without immediately suspecting it was a lie. The way he felt other people's pain so acutely that it crowded out his own, and he couldn't tell where their sadness ended and his began.

"Sometimes I don't know if I'm sad or if I'm just near someone who is," he said.

"And now?" Her voice was breathless. The toy was at fifteen percent and she was holding steady, her body adjusting, accommodating.

"Now I'm near you. And I can feel that you're carrying something. And I want to take it. But I also want to keep it because it means I'm touching something real about you."

"That's. Putain. That's a lot."

"Too much?"

"No. Don't stop."

He pushed to eighteen percent. She exhaled slowly. He could hear her settling into it, the way her body softened, the way the tension in her breathing eased into something warmer.

"Your turn," he said. "Tell me something you've never told anyone."

Silence. The kind that meant she was searching. Not for something to say but for the courage to say it.

"I don't know who I am," she said.

He waited.

"I know that sounds. I know everyone feels that. But I mean it literally. I don't know who I am. I've spent my whole life becoming what other people needed. My mother needed me to be good. My teachers needed me to be smart. My boyfriend needs me to be steady. And I've been all those things so well and for so long that I can't find the version of me that existed before I started performing. She might not exist anymore. She might have been smothered by all the versions I built on top of her."

"She exists."

"How do you know?"

"Because I can hear her. Right now. On this phone. She's the one who said I don't know who I am. The performed version would never say that. The performed version would say I'm fine or I'm just tired or I'm overthinking things. The real you is the one who admits she's lost."

She didn't speak for a long time. When she did, her voice was thick.

"How do you do that?"

"Do what?"

"Make me feel like the worst parts of me are the best parts."

"Because they are. The worst parts are the truest parts. And the truest parts are the only ones worth knowing."

He pushed to twenty. She moaned softly but didn't stop talking.

"I'm scared," she said.

"Of what?"

"That this is real. That you're real. That I've found someone who sees me and I'm going to destroy it because that's what I do. I destroy good things because I don't believe I deserve them."

"You won't destroy this."

"You don't know that."

"I know you. That's enough."

"You don't know me. You don't know my name."

"Your name is a sound someone gave you. I know the sound you make when you're close. That's more real than any name."

She came. Quietly. At twenty percent. Just from the conversation. Just from the low hum and the words and the intimacy of being known. She came with a small, startled gasp that sounded like surprise, as if her body had made the decision without her mind's permission.

"Sorry," she whispered.

"Don't you dare apologize for that."

"I didn't mean to. It just."

"You came because I was telling you the truth. Don't ever apologize for responding to truth."

She laughed, shaky and breathless. "Okay."

He brought the toy down to ten percent. A gentle pulse. She settled.

At noon, she showed him her village.

She took the phone outside and walked. He listened to the sounds of her world. Gravel underfoot. A road. A car passing in the distance. She narrated as she went, pointing out things he couldn't see but could picture through her voice.

"There's the boulangerie. It's closed on Thursdays. The old man who runs it is called Bernard and he always gives me an extra croissant because he thinks I'm too thin."

"You are too thin."

"How do you know that?"

"The photo of your hand. The wrist. I could see the bones."

She was quiet. "You really do notice everything."

"I notice you. That's different."

She kept walking. "There's the church. Twelfth century. The bell rings at seven every morning and it's the most beautiful sound I've ever heard. It sounds like the village is breathing."

"Send me a recording tomorrow morning."

"I will."

"And there's the field. The one from the photo. The one I showed you."

"I remember."

"It looks different in daylight. The stone wall is more. There's lichen on it. Yellow and green. And the sky is huge. I forget how huge it is until I stand here and look up."

"What are you thinking about?"

"I'm thinking about you. Standing on your cliffs. Looking at your sea. And me standing here looking at my fields. And the water between us."

"It's not that much water."

"It's enough."

"For some people. Not for us."

"You think so?"

"I know so."

She turned for home. He listened to her walk back, the gravel becoming pavement becoming the creak of her front door.

"Now you," she said. "Show me."

He took his phone outside. The wind was immediate, a constant pressure, carrying salt and cold. He walked to the end of his street and turned toward the sea.

"I can hear it," she said. "The wind."

"It never stops. I've told you."

"Show me the sea."

He held the phone up and took a photo. The Channel, gray and restless, stretching to the horizon. The white cliffs to the east, stark against the sky. The beach below, the rocks dark with wet. It was bleak and beautiful and entirely him.

He sent it.

"It's so gray," she said.

"I know."

"It suits you."

"Thanks. I think."

"No. I mean it. It's. You're like the sea. You look cold on the surface but there's so much moving underneath."

"That's the most you thing you've ever said."

She laughed. "I learned from the best."

He kept walking. The promenade. The railings. The steps down to the beach. He sat on the bottom step, the wind in his face, the phone pressed to his ear.

"I live in Folkestone," he said.

"I know. You told me."

"No. I mean. I live in Folkestone. Exactly. I'm sitting on the steps at the bottom of the Old High Street. If you wanted to find me, you could."

Silence.

"What are you saying?"

"I'm saying I trust you. With where I am. With who I am. You showed me your village. Your boulangerie. Your church. I want to give you the same."

"You know I could find you."

"I know."

"That doesn't scare you?"

"Everything scares me. You don't."

She was quiet for a long time. He could hear her breathing and the distant sound of a bird and the tick of the clock in her kitchen.

"I'm in Senlis," she said.

He knew Senlis. A medieval town. Cobblestones. An old cathedral. Halfway between Paris and the Oise countryside. Beautiful and quiet and exactly the kind of place where a woman who needed space would end up.

"Senlis," he repeated.

"Yes. If you wanted to find me. You could."

"I don't want to find you. I want you to tell me to come."

She inhaled sharply.

"Not yet," he said. "I know. But someday."

"Someday," she whispered.

Afternoon. The light shifted. The gray thinned to silver and the wind dropped to a breeze. They'd been on the phone for six hours.

The toy had been running at varying levels the entire time. Low during conversation. Higher during silence. He'd brought her to the edge three times and pulled back three times, and each time she'd gasped and whimpered and called him cruel in a voice that meant the opposite.

"I need you," she said finally.

"You have me."

"No. I need you. I need to hear you. I need to know I affect you the way you affect me."

"You know you do."

"I need to hear it."

He was sitting on his bed now. Curtains half drawn. The afternoon light striped across the floor. He was already hard. He'd been hard on and off for hours, the wanting building and receding like the tide, and now she was asking and the tide was coming in.

"What do you want me to do?" he asked.

"Touch yourself. Let me listen."

He did. He unbuttoned. He took himself in his hand. He didn't hide the sound. The first stroke, the sharp inhale, the low groan that came from his chest. She heard all of it.

"More," she whispered.

He stroked slowly. Eyes closed. Phone pressed to his ear. Her breathing in one ear and the sound of his own hand in the quiet room. He pushed the toy to twenty percent and heard her respond, a gasp that synchronized with his rhythm.

"Keep talking," she said. "Tell me what you're thinking."

"I'm thinking about you in your kitchen. On your table. I'm thinking about the photo you sent. Your waist. The curve of it. I want to put my hands there. I want to feel your skin against my palms."

She moaned.

"I'm thinking about your voice. The accent. The way you say putain when you lose control. It's the most beautiful sound I've ever heard."

"Keep going."

"I'm thinking about your hands. In my hair. Pulling me toward you. I'm thinking about your mouth. I don't even know what your mouth looks like but I'm thinking about it."

"You're going to make me come."

"Not yet."

"Please."

"Not yet. I want to be there first."

He stroked faster. His breathing was ragged now. He could hear her matching it, her breath rising with his, the toy humming inside her at twenty-two percent, and the synchronization of it was something he'd never experienced. Two bodies in two countries climbing toward the same peak at the same pace.

"Now," he said. "Now."

He came with a groan that filled the room. Low, raw, uncontained. She followed him, her cry sharp and high, and through the phone he could hear her body shaking, the chair creaking, the breath catching and breaking in waves.

Silence. Breathing.

"That was," she said.

"I know."

"How many times is that today?"

"For you?"

"For both of us."

"I've lost count."

"Same."

He smiled. He could hear her smiling.

Evening. The light faded. She made dinner. He made tea. They kept the line open. The mundane intimacy of hearing someone move through their evening was more intoxicating than the sex. The clatter of pans. The running of water. The cat meowing once, sharply, and being ignored.

"What did you make?" he asked.

"Pasta. Nothing complicated. I can't cook."

"I can."

"Show off."

"I'll cook for you someday."

She was quiet. The word someday hung between them again. He could feel it. The weight of a future they were building without meaning to, brick by brick, word by word, orgasm by orgasm.

"You keep saying things like that," she said.

"Things like what?"

"Someday. I'll cook for you. I'll wait for you. I'll come for you."

"I mean them."

"I know you do. That's what's terrifying."

He ate at his table. She ate at hers. They talked about food. About the difference between English and French cooking. About the time he tried to make a souffle and it collapsed. About the time she burned water, which she insisted was possible and he insisted was not.

The toy sat dormant. The conversation wandered. They talked about books. She read novels. Literary fiction. She liked stories about people who were sad in beautiful settings. He liked poetry. The kind that was almost prose. The kind that pretended not to be poetry because it was too embarrassed to call itself that.

"We're the same," she said.

"How?"

"We both like things that pretend not to be what they are."

He thought about that for a long time.

Night. Ten pm. She was on her sofa. He was on his bed. The phone call had been running for fifteen hours. Neither of them wanted to hang up.

"Tell me something you're afraid of," she said.

"Being known."

"You just told me where you live."

"That's different. That's trust. Being known is. Someone seeing the thing you're most ashamed of and still choosing to stay. I've never had that."

"You think if I saw the real you I'd leave?"

"I think everyone leaves eventually. The question is whether they leave because they saw too much or because they saw enough."

"That's bleak."

"I'm bleak."

"I like bleak."

"I know you do."

She was quiet. Then: "I'm afraid of being alone."

"You're not alone. You have a boyfriend."

"That's not the same thing as not being alone. He's there. But he doesn't see me. I could disappear inside the relationship and he wouldn't notice for months. Maybe years. I'm afraid that I already have."

"Then why do you stay?"

"Because it's safe. Because leaving is harder than staying. Because being alone is the thing I'm afraid of and the relationship is the shield I use to keep it away."

"That's not a relationship. That's a hiding place."

"I know."

He pushed the toy to fifteen percent. She caught her breath. The day's play had sensitized her. Every pulse was amplified. He could bring her to the edge with almost nothing now.

"I'm also afraid of you," she said.

"Of me?"

"Of what you make me feel. Of how much I want this. Of how quickly this has become the thing I think about when I wake up and the thing I think about before I sleep. That's not normal. We've known each other for two weeks."

"Time is different in the dark."

"What does that mean?"

"It means the hours we spend together are more honest than the hours most people spend in years. Intensity isn't measured in duration. It's measured in depth. We've gone deeper in two weeks than most people go in a decade."

"You're doing it again."

"Doing what?"

"Making the terrifying sound reasonable."

He pushed to twenty. She moaned. Soft. Tired. The arousal was different at night. Slower. Heavier. More about comfort than release.

"I want to show you something," she said.

A photo. Her face. Finally. Partially obscured by her hair, dark and loose, falling across one side. But the other side was visible. An eye. A cheekbone. The corner of a mouth, slightly parted. The light was amber from a lamp. Her skin looked warm. She looked tired and real and human.

He stared at it for a long time.

"You're beautiful," he said.

"You don't have to say that."

"I know I don't. That's why it matters when I do."

"Putain." Her voice was thick. "You can't keep saying things like that."

"Why?"

"Because I'm going to fall in love with you."

"You already have."

Silence. Long. The kind that confirmed everything.

"I'm going to fall in love with you," she repeated.

"I know."

"And you?"

"I've been falling since the first voice note."

"That's. You can't. You don't even know my name."

"I know the sound of your breathing. I know the shape of your silence. I know what you sound like when you come and I know what you sound like when you're holding back tears. That's more than most people learn in a lifetime."

She made a sound. Small. A breath that was almost a sob.

"Don't," she whispered.

"Don't what?"

"Don't be this person. Don't be exactly what I need. I don't know what to do with it."

"You don't have to do anything with it. Just let it be there."

They played again at midnight. Slower this time. Less urgent. He held the toy at a low pulse while she talked him through his own release. Her voice was steady, commanding. She told him when to move and when to stop and when to let go and he obeyed her completely. When he came, it was quiet. A long exhale. A surrender. She heard it and responded, her own climax following his, triggered by the sound of him giving in.

After, they were quiet for a long time. The phone was warm. Their breathing was synchronized. The house was dark. The cat had settled somewhere unseen.

"What time do you have to get up?" he asked.

"Six. He'll be home by two in the afternoon. I need to clean. Air the house. Be. Normal."

"Be the performance."

"Yes."

"I'm sorry."

"Don't be. This is my choice. My mess."

"And what time do you have to be at work?" she asked.

"Eight. But I won't sleep."

"You should try."

"I can't." He paused. "Not without hearing your voice."

"I'll stay on until you fall asleep," he said.

"You will?"

"I'll stay on until you fall asleep. And then I'll hang up. And then I'll lie here and listen to the wind and think about you."

"That's not fair," she said.

"What isn't?"

"You give everything. I don't know how to give back the same amount."

"You don't have to give the same amount. You just have to stay."

"I'm staying."

"I know."

She was quiet. He could hear her breathing slow. The cat purred somewhere, a distant motor. The clock ticked. The wind pressed.

"NorthForeland?" she said.

"Yes."

"I want to meet you."

His chest cracked.

"I know."

"I'm not ready yet."

"I know that too."

"But I want to."

"Then I'll wait."

"You keep saying that."

"Because it keeps being true."

"I'm going to sleep now," she said.

"Okay."

"Don't hang up yet."

"I won't."

"Talk to me. About anything. I just want to hear your voice while I fall asleep."

He talked. About the sea. About the cliffs. About the way the light changed in Folkestone at dawn, from black to gray to a thin, pale gold that lasted ten minutes and then vanished. About the coffee shop on the Old High Street that made terrible coffee but played good music. About the ferry port and the trains and the way you could stand on the promenade and look south and know that France was there, just beyond the curve of the water, just beyond the horizon.

"Senlis isn't that far," he said.

"No."

"A few hours. A train. A ferry. You could be here by lunchtime."

"Don't."

"I'm not saying now. I'm saying. It's possible. The distance is real but it's not impossible. Nothing between us is impossible."

"You're going to make me cry."

"I'm going to make you come first."

She laughed. Sleepy. Warm. "You're insatiable."

"Only for you."

"Goodnight, NorthForeland."

"Goodnight, Oise. Sleep."

Her breathing slowed. He listened. Five minutes. Ten. Fifteen. The breathing deepened. Evened. She was asleep. The phone was still connected. He could hear the tick of her clock and the silence of her house and the faint sound of the wind through her open window, the same wind that was pressing against his.

He stayed on the line for another twenty minutes. Just listening. Just breathing. Then he hung up, gently, and lay in the dark.

The alarm was set for six. He had three hours of sleep ahead of him. He didn't care. He'd run on the sound of her breathing for weeks if he had to.

He closed his eyes. The wind moaned. Somewhere across the water, in a stone house in Senlis, a woman he'd never touched was sleeping with his voice still in her ears.

He smiled in the dark. It was the first time in a long time the darkness smiled back.